Apparently, we’ve found another way to make job interviews more stressful. Alongside researching the company, preparing examples and working out how to describe your weaknesses without accidentally listing reasons not to employ you, there’s now a beverage assessment.
Bring an iced coffee to a job interview and you might look too casual. Not sufficiently serious. Possibly like someone who has other things to do that day, which, inconveniently, you probably do.
The debate gathered attention after recruiter Caitlin Wehniainen advised candidates against arriving with iced coffees, particularly in formal corporate settings. She later clarified that she wasn’t calling coffee drinkers bad candidates; her concern was the impression they could create and avoiding distractions.I understand the advice. I’m considerably less impressed by the standard that makes it necessary.
Has the Coffee Applied for the Job?
If I’m interviewing someone, I want to know whether they’ve prepared, understand the role and can give me something beyond the phrases they think I’m hoping to hear. I’m interested in how they listen, explain themselves and treat the people around them.
I cannot imagine getting to the end of a genuinely good conversation and thinking, “Excellent candidate. Shame about the caramel.”
Of course, first impressions matter. Arriving late without an explanation, scrolling through your phone or speaking dismissively to someone would give me concerns. Those behaviours tell me something about consideration and judgement.
A drink sitting beside someone tells me they’ve brought a drink. I’d like a little more evidence before giving it responsibility for their entire professional reputation.
So, Who Made These Rules?
What interests me is how confidently people talk about professionalism, as though we all received the same handbook and some candidates simply couldn’t be bothered to read it.
We didn’t.
Some interview expectations make obvious sense: be prepared, pay attention, respect people’s time. Others seem to depend on whether the person opposite you recognises your version of looking serious.
A bottle of water is acceptable. A coffee offered by the interviewer might be perfectly acceptable. Arrive carrying your own cold one and suddenly we’re discussing whether you understand the workplace.
I’m struggling to find the moment when the ice becomes a character reference.
There’s also something uncomfortable about expecting candidates to anticipate preferences we haven’t explained. If a workplace has a practical reason for restricting drinks, say so. People can follow a clear instruction. Guessing which harmless habit someone secretly dislikes is a rather different exercise.
You Can Have Standards Without Being Precious
I’m not suggesting someone should arrive juggling breakfast, conduct the interview between mouthfuls and ask where to plug in their smoothie maker.
Read the room. Put your drink somewhere sensible. Don’t leave a wet ring on the desk or spend someone’s answer enthusiastically excavating the final ice cube with a straw.
But those are ordinary considerations around noise, mess and attention. We can assess the behaviour as it happens instead of deciding the cup has already told us everything.
And I’d apply those expectations to the interviewer too. If you’re checking emails while a candidate answers, your own coffee being in a respectable ceramic mug doesn’t rescue the situation.Job interview etiquette should involve both people making an effort. The person with the vacancy hasn’t automatically won the manners competition.
Would I Tell Someone to Bring One?
Honestly, if someone asked for the lowest-risk approach to a formal interview, I’d suggest finishing it beforehand. They want the job, and I wouldn’t make their application the testing ground for my opinion about unnecessary rules.
I can give that advice while still thinking some employers need to examine what they’re judging.
Candidates have enough to demonstrate in a short conversation. Employers should be able to explain how the things they notice relate to the person’s suitability. “It looked a bit casual” deserves a follow-up question, especially when everything the candidate actually said suggested they’d taken the opportunity seriously.
I’d Be Watching the Interviewer Too
An interview gives both sides information. If an employer becomes noticeably bothered by a harmless drink, I’d want to understand what else they consider evidence of a bad attitude.
Can people ask questions? Admit uncertainty? Have a different way of doing something? Or does fitting in involve a running assessment of tiny preferences nobody has bothered to explain?
I want people to take their work seriously. I also think we should take hiring seriously enough to assess something more substantial than their coffee order.
Would an iced coffee genuinely put you off a candidate, or have we given a plastic cup rather too much authority?
Can an Iced Coffee Really Ruin a Job Interview?
Apparently, we’ve found another way to make job interviews more stressful. Alongside researching the company, preparing examples and working out how to describe your weaknesses without accidentally...
3 October 2026
3 Mins Read
18
Views
0
Comments