
We want real. Local. Meaningful.
There are few things modern travellers seem to want more than an “authentic experience”.
We want real. Local. Meaningful. Something that gets us underneath the surface of a place and gives us a story slightly more interesting than we went to the beach and then had dinner. What we apparently don’t want is anything that feels manufactured for tourists.
Except we’d also quite like excellent reviews, online booking, an English-speaking guide, clear directions, card payments and free cancellation until 24 hours before.
Suddenly, authenticity has quite a complicated job to do.
We’ve created this idea that the best travel experiences are the ones that simply happen. The restaurant we stumble across. The conversation with someone we meet. The tiny festival we didn’t know was happening. Those moments absolutely can be brilliant.
But some of the best experiences I’ve had while travelling have also started with a booking confirmation.
So when did planning something make it less real?
Can you book authenticity?
Search for things to do almost anywhere and somebody will sell you the “authentic” version. Authentic cooking classes, authentic village experiences, authentic local dinners, authentic cultural tours.
There is something slightly odd about pressing BOOK NOW on authenticity.
But I don’t automatically think that makes the experience meaningless.
If a family teaches visitors recipes they’ve cooked for generations and earns money from doing it, does the fact I’ve paid make the food less real? If a guide is being paid to explain their city to me, does that make their knowledge less genuine? If a cultural performance happens at 7pm every evening because that’s when visitors arrive, does that automatically strip it of its value?
Sometimes, perhaps.
There are experiences that package culture into something easier to sell. There are performances, encounters and supposedly traditional activities that exist largely because visitors will pay for them. We should be able to question that, particularly when the people or traditions being presented have very little control over how they’re being used.
But commercial and fake aren’t automatically the same thing.
Tourism is an industry. People make their living from it. Sometimes the person giving you an incredible insight into a place is doing so because it’s their job.
I’m completely fine with that.
Why do we think the best travel happens by accident?
There’s a certain kind of travel story we love. We got completely lost and found this tiny place . . . or we started talking to this man and he invited us . . . or the ultimate traveller badge of honour: there wasn’t another tourist anywhere.
They’re great stories because they couldn’t have been planned. But I don’t think spontaneity automatically makes an experience better.
I’ve worked in travel for well over a decade and one thing I know for certain is that organised doesn’t necessarily mean boring. Sometimes booking the tour gets you access you wouldn’t otherwise have. Sometimes the guide knows something you would have walked straight past. Sometimes the activity that looks extremely touristy online ends up being the thing you talk about most when you get home.
And sometimes wandering around hoping something magical happens just means you wander around for three hours and get hungry.
There is room for both.
I like the unexpected bits of travel. I also like knowing that at 9am tomorrow I’m going somewhere I’ve really wanted to see and somebody who knows considerably more about it than I do is going to show me around.
One doesn’t have to be more authentic than the other.
Maybe we’re asking the wrong question
Perhaps Is this authentic? isn’t particularly useful.
Authentic according to whom?
Places aren’t frozen at the point in history we find most interesting. Traditions change. Food changes. Neighbourhoods change. People who live in beautiful old towns also own iPhones, order takeaway and occasionally want something for dinner that isn’t the traditional dish visitors have been told they absolutely must eat.
Yet when we travel, we sometimes expect places to perform a particular version of themselves for us.
We want Japan to feel Japanese enough. Italy to feel Italian enough. A Caribbean island to look sufficiently Caribbean. Then we call the experience authentic when reality matches the version we’d already imagined.
I think that’s where the word starts to fall apart.
Perhaps what we’re really searching for isn’t authenticity at all. Maybe we’re looking for connection.
We want to understand something we didn’t understand before. We want to eat something with a story behind it, hear from somebody who knows the place or do something that couldn’t simply be copied and pasted into another trip.
That can happen completely by accident.
I’ll keep booking the experience
I’m not giving up spontaneous travel. Some of the best moments really are the ones you couldn’t have planned. But I’m definitely not going to pretend that booking something somehow makes me less adventurous.
If I want to go on the boat trip, I’m booking the boat trip. If there’s an incredible food tour, I’ll do the food tour. If someone can take me somewhere I couldn’t sensibly get to alone and explain what I’m looking at when I arrive, even better.
I don’t need every experience to prove that I’ve somehow accessed the “real” version of a place. I just want it to be worth doing.
Because maybe that’s the question we should have been asking all along.
Not was it authentic?
Was it good?
Did I learn something? Did I enjoy it? Did it help me understand the place a little better? Would I tell a friend to spend their money on it?
If the answer is yes, I’m not particularly bothered whether I stumbled across it accidentally or booked it online three months earlier.
And knowing me, I probably booked it.